A nineteenth century cabinet photograph made by Needham in New Castle [Henry County], Indiana shows a young woman in a rustling silk gown resting her hand on the shoulder of a seated, mustached young man. On the back, someone wrote simply “Barton & Flora, May 1883.” The clearly written names are not the strongest clues in making identification; in fact, they led to misidentification, a reminder that photograph identification takes more than a name.

Couple 1: Barton L. Butler and Flora M. Bogue
Of course there are two possibilities for which couple posed for the photograph.
Barton L. Butler and Flora M. Bogue married on 20 October 1886.1 The next day The Cambridge City Tribune reported, “On last evening Rev. Retts united in marriage Barton L. Butler and Flora M. Bogue, at the residence of W. O. Bogue, west of Dublin.”2
In 1880 census enumerators visited Diza Butler’s household, where twenty-one-year-old Barton lived, and a few pages later recorded William O. Bogue, a farmer, with his wife Mary A., sixteen-year-old Flora.3
If the photograph dates from 1883, and Barton and Flora did not marry until 1886, is this an engagement photograph? Did someone confuse the years? The tiniest of details shows that it was not the Butlers.
Couple 2: Barton W. Fairfield and Flora C. Bond
Who knew there could be two Barton and Floras in Henry County! Flora C. Bond (aged 13) lived in Calvin and Mary Bond’s household in New Castle.4 Flora, using the name Clara F., married Barton W. Fairfield in 1877 in Henry County.5 In 1880 Barton Fairfield (aged 31) and his wife Flora (aged 22) lived in New Castle.6
If the photograph dates from 1883, then Barton and Flora Fairfield were already married.
Photograph Identification Clues: A Portrait in ‘May 1883
The photograph was taken in New Castle, the Henry County seat. A New Castle business directory for 1884 lists “Wint Needham” as a photographer at 121 South Main Street, which supports the date on the back of the card. The portrait is a cabinet photograph, printed on card stock, measuring 4.25 inches by 6.5 inches. The production style is also true to the period as larger cabinet prints overtook the popularity of smaller carte de visite photographs.
The clothing agrees with the date. Flora wears a long, close-fitting bodice, with the overskirt pulled back and draped over a finely pleated and gathered underskirt. The look belongs to the early 1880s, when the bustle was returning to fashion. Her white lace collar and cuffs, drop earrings, and a bracelet finish the outfit. Barton wears a jacket and long trousers that appear to be cut from the same fabric. He also wears a vest buttoned high on the chest, a small bow tie, and a full mustache.
But which Barton and Flora?
Religious Differences
Friends’ (Quaker) Meeting Records listed Barton L. Butler’s birth.7 Barton L. Butler and Flora M. Bogue, recorded with their respective families, appeared consecutively in Friends’ records.8 If Barton and Flora (Bogue) Butler were raised within the Society of Friends, then one might expect a simpler dress, but perhaps the couple did not adhere to the plain attire often adopted by Quakers.
The marriage announcements for each couple show their unions were solemnized with Protestant rites. Elder J. B. Ludwig officiated at the Fairfields’ wedding in 1877.9 Ludwig preached at Christian Churches in Indiana near the time the couple married.10 Barton W. Fairfield’s father, Lorenzo D. Fairfield, in his will made bequests to the Christian Chapel in Batavia, Ohio, and to Union Christian College in Merom, Indiana, an institution founded by the Christian Church denomination.11
Rev. Retts solemnized the union of the Butlers in 1886, and he was the Rev. Retts (also printed Rhetts) who preached preached at the Methodist Episcopal Church in Centerville in adjoining Wayne County, Indiana.12
Two Protestant weddings, so which Barton and Flora are in the photograph?
Finding the Hidden Handwriting
When the back of the card was photographed and enlarged on a computer screen, faint handwriting became discernible. Written down the right side of the back of the photograph were the words “To L. D. Fairfield May 30 1883” (see Figure 1). This message puts the photograph directly into the hands of the Fairfield family rather than the Butler or Bogue families. A census enumerator in 1870 placed Barton in Lorenzo D. Fairfield’s home in Clermont County, Ohio.13 A local Henry County newspaper announced in 1882 Barton’s father had died in Clermont County, Ohio.14 The report was premature: Lorenzo signed his will in July 1886, and it was recorded that August.15 In 1897 his widow, Elizabeth Fairfield, named her deceased husband Lorenzo D. Fairfield and his son Barton W. in her own will.16
Figure 1

Back of photograph, showing the L.D. Fairfield inscription.
Barton W. Fairfield (aged 51) and his wife, identified as Florance (aged 43) lived in Jay County, Indiana, in 1900.17 Flora died in October 1900.18 Seven years later, Barton, married Anna Belle Dial in Clermont County, Ohio.19 Barton signed the marriage record with a distinctive left-facing F (see Figure 2).
Looking At the Back And Comparing Signatures
Finding the lightly inscribed message to L.D. Fairfield puts the photograph into the hands of the subject’s father, but are there clues in the handwriting? When Barton remarried he signed the marriage record (see Figure 2) which can be compared with the writing on the back of the photograph (see Figure 3). Although both writing samples share a similar left-facing F, the handwriting differs, perhaps because decades separate the samples, or because a different hand wrote the inscription.
Figure 2

Figure 3

Conclusion
When religious practices and handwriting samples fail to support a conclusion, the subjects’ clothing, photographer, photograph style, location, and documentary evidence point to this as a photograph of Barton W. Fairfield and his wife, Flora “Clara” Bond, made in 1883 and probably given to Barton’s father, Lorenzo D. Fairfield.
What’s Next…
In my next post I delve into photographer’s cardstock with another example from New Castle’s Wint Needham.
FEATURED IMAGE: “Court House, New Castle, Ind.,” postcard, sent to Oliver Werking, Eaton, Indiana, postmarked 24 November 1908, author’s collection.
- Henry County, Indiana, Marriages, 7:519, Barton L. Butler and Flora M. Bogue, 20 October 1886; imaged, “Indiana, Marriages, 1811-2019,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HY-XCH9-9G2) > Image Group Number (IGN) 004109831 > image 143.
- “On Last Evening…,” Marriage Announcement, Barton L. Butler and Flora M. Bogue, The Cambridge City [Indiana] Tribune, 21 October 1886, page 3, column 4; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/15136564/)
- 1880 U.S. census, Henry County, Indiana, population schedule, ED 16, Dudley Township, page 284-A (stamped), dwelling 46, family 50, Flora M. Bogue in William O. Bogue household; imaged, “United States, Census, 1880,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33SQ-GYBM-96PY). Also, page 282-A (stamped), dwelling 6, family 7, Barton L. Butler in Diza Butler household.
- 1870 U.S. Census, Henry County, Indiana, population schedule, New Castle, page 20, dwelling 146, family 152, Flora C. Bond in Calvin Bond household; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HT-DYCS-JS4).
- Henry County, Indiana, Marriages, 5:591, Barton W. Fairfield and Clara F., 5 September 1877; imaged, “Indiana, Marriages, 1780-1992,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HY-6QP3-H6K).
- 1880 U.S. census, Henry County, Indiana, population schedule, ED10, New Castle Township, page 163C, dwelling/family 243, Barton Fairfield household; imaged, “United States, Census, 1880,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33S7-9YBM-9XNK).
- Milford Monthly Meeting, Wayne Co., Indiana, Birth Records, Book A: page 130, Barton L. Butler, 24 July 1858; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C34V-3YXH) > IGN 008618647 image 83.
- Members of Dublin Meeting, list, unpaginated, Barton L. Butler, 1 Jan 1876; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C34V-3YKD) > IGN 008618647 > image 113. Also on same page, Flora M. Bogue.
- “Married…At The Bride’s Home…,” New Castle Mercury (Indiana), 6 September 1877, page 3, column 3; imaged, NewspaperArchive (https://access.newspaperarchive.com/us/indiana/new-castle/new-castle-mercury/1877/09-06/page-3).
- “Brownsburg,” Elder Ludwig, The Hendricks County Union (Indiana), 4 October 1877, page 2, column 5; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/1290370529). Also, “The Disciples of Christ denomination…,” Richmond Daily Independent (Indiana), 22 November 1877, page 4, column 1; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/1045711492/).
- Clermont County, Ohio, Wills, : 426-428, L.D. Fairfield, 31 July 1886; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89MG-Q9WP-R) > IGN 005439946 > image 249. Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Union_Christian_College,_Merom), Union Christian College, Merom, revised 3:05, 6 September 2026.
- “On Last Evening…,” Marriage Announcement, Barton L. Butler and Flora M. Bogue, The Cambridge City Tribune (Indiana), 21 October 1886, page 3, column 4; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/15136564/). Also, “Cambridge City,” Rev. Retts, The Sunday Register (Richmond, Indiana), 26 April 1885, page 8, column 4; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/1045635101/). Announcing Rev. Retts moving to be the clergyman at the Methodist church in Richmond, Indiana. “Centerville,” Rev. Rhetts, pastor of the M.E. church, Richmond Daily Palladium (Indiana), 29 May 1901, page 6, column 3; imaged, NewspaperArchive (https://access.newspaperarchive.com/us/indiana/richmond/richmond-daily-palladium/1901/05-27/page-6).
- 1870 U.S. census, Clermont County, Ohio, population schedule, Batavia Township, page 13 (stamped), dwelling 191, family 190, Barton W. S. Fairfield in Lorenzo D. Fairfield household; imaged, “United States, Census, 1870,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HT-DZ57-5WG).
- “The Father of Barton Fairfield…,” New Castle Democrat (Indiana), 5 October 1882, page 3, column 3; imaged, NewspaperArchive (https://access.newspaperarchive.com/us/indiana/new-castle/new-castle-democrat/1882/10-05/page-3).
- Clermont County, Ohio, Wills, O: 426-428, L.D. Fairfield, 31 July 1886.
- Clermont County, Ohio, Wills, :383-385, Elizabeth B. Fairfield, 22 July 1897; imaged, “Ohio, Probate Records, 1789-1996,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89MP-S4D8).
- 1900 U.S. census, Jay County, Indiana, population schedule, ED 69, Richland Township, sheet 4B, dwelling 84, family 86, Barton Fairfield household; imaged, “United States, Census, 1900,” FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:S3HT-DC19-JPS).
- Indiana State Board of Health, Death Records, Jay County, 1900, volume 113, page 252, no. 96, 21 October 1900, Richland Township, Clara Florence Fairfield; imaged, “Indiana, U.S., Death Certificates, 1899-2017,” Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/60716/images/45232_354292-00311).
- Clermont County, Ohio, Marriages, 1907-1910, page 20, Barton W. Fairfield and Anna Belle Dial, 25 October 1907; imaged, “Ohio, U.S., County Marriage Records, 1774-1993,” Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/61378/images/TH-267-12047-132857-60).

